Death by dehydration can't cause euphoria
On March 28, Laura Gaffney wrote that Terri Schiavo was not "experiencing the feelings of starvation or dehydration" and that "during the end stages of dehydration one typically experiences a feeling of euphoria."
In order to be so certain of what Terri Schiavo was feeling, Gaffney must have some sort of telekinetic bond with her. This comes as a great relief. During this ordeal, I thought back to times when I have been hungry and thirsty (and there were times when I was extremely hungry and thirsty), and I felt anything but euphoric.
Has Laura ever seen pictures of the poor people in Africa? Does that look like euphoria in their hollow, sunken, pleading eyes? Perhaps Laura, and those who believe as she does, should visit Africa to let them know that their suffering will soon give way to euphoria.
It is more likely that Laura, and those who think like her, are in a situation very different from Terri Schiavo and are trying to make themselves feel better because what they believe led, indirectly to be sure, to the slow, torturous death of one of God's children.
Matt Zukowski
Browns Summit
Comments (8)
To report abuse of the comment feature on this site, please use the feedback form at the bottom of any page.
Just go chain your dog to a tree in the backyard and watch it slowly starve to death and tell me that it's "euphoric" or a "thing of beauty" as one of the other regular posters here called it.
Callous, cruel, and inhumane, that's what it really is.
Posted on April 4, 2005 11:08 AM
Hunger is fun. That's why everyone in this country is so skinny. Yeah, that's the ticket!
Posted on April 4, 2005 11:15 AM
I don't know what Ms. Shiavo experienced as she died. I suspect the health professionals made sure that she was sedated and that as far as is humanly possible she felt nothing.
That said I'll repeat what I've said before. If we decide that we are going to let someone die then we should have the courage to kill them humanely. There is no moral difference between letting a comotose person die and killing them. By passively letting someone die I think we feel as if that somehow takes the responsibility off of us. It doesn't.
Posted on April 4, 2005 12:26 PM
I do not know personally what dehydration feels like, at least not in the sense of dying from it. However, that does not invalidate the right of someone to make an opinionated post.
However, what strikes me as so humorous is that many of the people who post stupendous replies to letters rarely, if ever, have an email available whereby any dialogue can be pursued. That is sad. Yet, it speaks volumes to the character of the ones making those repsonses.
Posted on April 4, 2005 3:39 PM
Terri Schiavo did not have a cerebral cortex. Basically, she did not have a brain. She was not conscious or self-aware and could not think or have any feelings. It really is doubtful whether she could suffer.
All that was left of her was her body, and that was being kept grotesquely alive. Her parents would have amputated all four of her limbs to keep her torso alive, and they said that they would keep her body alive even if she had had a living will specifically requesting not to be kept alive. Clearly they were not acting on Terri's behalf, no matter what they say. They were projecting their own problems onto her poor body.
I am glad for her sake that she was finally allowed to die, and I would want the same for myself if I were beyond recovery and beyond suffering, as she was.
Posted on April 4, 2005 5:44 PM
I agree with Marshall. If the courts rule that she should die, at least give her a quick injection. It's asinine to just remove the feeding tube so that you're merely "allowing" her to die, rather than killing her.
Posted on April 4, 2005 6:53 PM
"However, what strikes me as so humorous is that many of the people who post stupendous replies to letters rarely, if ever, have an email available whereby any dialogue can be pursued. That is sad. Yet, it speaks volumes to the character of the ones making those repsonses"
Dialogues can be accomplished here for everyone to see. Some of us prefer not to give our e-mail out for a variety of reasons; NOT because we are afraid to discuss issues.
Posted on April 5, 2005 10:14 AM
It bothers me that this man's mistress was in the room with Ms. Schiavo when she died, but they wouldn't allow her mom to be in there. That is just wrong.
Posted on April 6, 2005 1:32 PM