The following is a Counterpoint column:
By Robert Healy
In a recent speech, President Bush said, "Many advocating an artificial timetable for withdrawing our troops are sincere, but I believe they're sincerely wrong."
Let's see who is wrong.
The phrase "artificial timetable" is ridiculous. There must always be set parameters for all military actions, period. That is, unless the goal is imperialistic domination.
This administration had no real parameters in place. They ignored the region's history, our generals and strategic experts. In fact, they ignored everyone but themselves.
Furthermore, recall the revelation that there was no exit strategy prior to our unnecessary invasion. No forethought was given beyond the cinematic "shock and awe" that Rumsfeld sought. No plans made for Iraq's security and stability. No concern for the much-needed infrastructures that would have assured a viable transition from dictatorship to democracy.
Not a thought was given to the possibility that relatives of the tens of thousands of innocent civilians killed might not take kindly to their "liberators," or that others would choose to seek power in the newly made political vacuum for themselves.
Now, more than two years in, Bush comes up with another absurdly misnamed policy, "Victory in Iraq." The self-contradiction is tragic. The result of this administration's incompetence is clear: dead soldiers, dead civilians and the stirrings of possible civil war.
A well thought-out, reasonably timed withdrawal plan is not "cut and run" but intelligent foreign policy.
At this point, what Bush "believes" is irrelevant. After the military triumphed, it was the political goals that needed to be reached for complete success. Instead, vanity ruled the administration's actions. Now chaos rules Iraq.
"Pulling our troops out before they've achieved their purpose is not a plan for victory," Bush said. Our soldiers continue to suffer because his doctrine is a failure.
Bush is wrong: The troops' purpose was achieved. His wasn't.
The writer lives in High Point.