Moore's movie marred by inaccuracies
The following is a Counterpoint column.
By Paula Pile
My husband and I watched Michael Moore's new movie "Sicko" with some excitement, only to be disappointed for a couple of reasons. I think that his heart was in the right place, but he missed the boat at least twice.
Moore produced a long segment on managed-care companies and their huge compensation packages. What he did not address as adequately was their impact on health care providers. I have been a panel member for several managed health care companies for more than 12 years and none of their reimbursement rates have gone up in over those years.
The N.C. State Employees Health plan decided to offer its members an option of one of two managed health care plans. The amount of reimbursement to the mental health care providers was reduced by roughly one-third. This means my pay for treating these patients was one-third less than it was one year ago. Most people in the private sector would not be happy with no raises in over 12 years and, in fact, a reduction of income due to fewer people with indemnity plans and the need for more secretarial help to do the massive amount of paper work required.
Moore's segment on the Cuban health care system was very inaccurate.
He missed out on an opportunity to deal with how our blockade has hurt the Cubans' access to medications. I have traveled to Cuba six times on mission trips with First Presbyterian Church. We brought much-needed medications to the Cuban citizens. The churches in Cuba gave those medications to citizens in their communities under the supervision of physicians who are church members. Plenty of the dentists and physicians we have met are unable to work due to the lack of medicines and supplies that result from our embargo. We took catheter bags and sterile gloves to a hospital that had none for its doctors and patients.
All I can say is that the ailing 9/11 rescue workers Moore took to Cuba for treatment must have been seen in Fidel's hospital by his personal health care providers. This is not the situation for your typical Cuban.
The writer is a licensed marriage and family therapist who lives in Greensboro.
Comments (11)
To report abuse of the comment feature on this site, please use the feedback form at the bottom of any page.
Would anyone like to start a donation drive for the poor Presbyterian therapists of Greensboro who hasn't had a raise in 12 years?
Posted on July 6, 2007 9:41 AM
It's so easy even a therapist can do it.
Posted on July 6, 2007 9:42 AM
“Moore produced a long segment on managed-care companies and their huge compensation packages. What he did not address as adequately was their impact on health care providers.”
Paula, I think, is the one who missed the boat. Paula says none of the reimbursement rates to health care providers have gone up for 12 years. So, from her standpoint, the doctors and therapists have been treated unfairly – how sad. However, I can guarantee you HMO premiums to patients have risen yearly (probably far more for individuals than for the employees of the N.C. State Employees Health Plan, who have bargaining power with the HMOs). So the premiums go up while the actual cost (i.e. reimbursements to health care providers) stays the same. Where do the increased profits to the HMOs go? Could it be for “huge compensation packages”? Didn’t Paula just prove the point the movie was trying to make? Good work!
I looked around on the internet and found out a lot what Paula says about Cuba is true. Despite some critical shortages of medical supplies due to the effect of U.S. embargo, both direct and indirect, Cuba still has a very highly rated health care system and one of the highest doctor to patient ratios. However, they also have a $40 million plus for profit business treating foreign patients. This health care is apparently better than for the average Cuban and does not suffer from the same shortages, but is considerably cheaper than what is offered in the U.S. However, this is going to be true of almost any country in the world. My son has limited income. He has lived in places near the Mexican border and routinely crossed over to get medical and dental care and prescription medications. He says the care is every bit as good as what he received in the U.S. and much, much cheaper. The prescription drugs, of course, come from the same companies that price gouge Americans.
Posted on July 6, 2007 11:34 AM
LastVOR,
Great points. Unfortunately, they are points that will be dismissed by the right wingers who are shills for the corporations who run the country.
As a great person once said, "Forgive them, for they know not what they do".
Posted on July 6, 2007 3:30 PM
Add the name "PAULA PILE" to the list of names that have great alliteration. Speaking of the "piles", where's neocon on this lte?
Posted on July 6, 2007 3:42 PM
As I understand it - Fidel made it a point to use the soviet funding to well-train Cubans in the medical fields. He then sent out many many teams to - especially central America - but really all over the world -letting Drs. provide world class service to demonstrate the goodness of Fidelism.
Pretty clever when you think of it - and had the soviet's not collapsed due to 1) death of the last of the old guard (around 1980) and 2) political stupidity of the new guard (specifically Gorby) .. Fidelism would still be a major thorn in our side.
Consider this - The destitute get highly valued medical care form Fidel, they get their crops stolen by American Corporations .. who The destitute gonna appreciate?
Posted on July 6, 2007 5:13 PM
James,
You have made the matrix of the topic, manifest.
Posted on July 6, 2007 9:26 PM
Here is an interesting article;
http://news.yahoo.com/s/hsn/20070706/hl_hsn/medicaltourismtakesflight
Shalom
Posted on July 6, 2007 10:30 PM
I'm doing this by memory so forgive if I'm a little off. We have a better health care system than Cuba as rated by the W. H. O.
They are 39th in the world while we're 37th.
Whooo hooo! We're number 37. We're number 37.
Take that Cuba!
We're the equivalent of the Yankees with the 200 million dollar payroll and sub .500 record.
Posted on July 7, 2007 3:24 AM
.. no further comments from the O'Reilly School of Oversimplification and Half-Data-Only folks?
Posted on July 7, 2007 6:45 AM
Looks as if neo and Danny have run for the hills with their tails tucked betwixt their legs.
Here Kitty, Kitty, kitty, Kitty!
Posted on July 7, 2007 10:10 AM