The following is a Counterpoint:
By Robert Hudson
Salim Muwakkil (column, Sept. 12) tries to explain why fewer blacks are joining the military these days, but none of his arguments holds water. For Muwakkil, the answer is simple: It's all George Bush's fault. If Bush hadn't started this war, the problem wouldn't exist.
But is that really the problem? Let's ask ourselves what the reason should be for joining the military. To me, a Vietnam artillery vet who enlisted, the answer is simple. You join the military to defend your country from enemies. That's what the military does.
It has a job to do, and an important one. If it fails, your economic situation just may be one of your lesser worries. The military needs men, and women, who can do that job, do it well and do it without complaint.
If you are "opposed to war for moral reasons," as the column says, guess what, Sport? You do not belong in the military. If you joined the Army just to get an education, you don't belong in the military. That's just a perk, like having a company car or employer-provided medical insurance.
If you are hoping, as Muwakkil seems to be saying, to get through three or four years without having to go to combat, that is a good sign that you are probably a sane person. At the same time, a soldier has to realize that he may be called upon to give all, up to and including his life, at any time. My God, man, we've been at war with the same people for more than 20 years, even though it has just been of late that someone decided that their side would no longer be the only one doing the fighting.
Muwakkil also cites "... the negative attitude that blacks have of George Bush." That's another thing; a soldier has to follow orders, or unnecessary loss of life can happen. War is dangerous, nasty business, and if you don't do your job because you don't happen to like the boss, from squad leader to commander-in-chief, someone may die. If you can't understand that, you don't belong in the military.
The military is for the man or woman who is willing to stand between the wolves and the sheep. And, if you believe that the United States is the wolf, you really, really don't belong in the military.
The writer lives in Pelham.