The following is a Counterpoint column.
By Deborah Kelly
I appreciate the clarity in the message that the News & Record editorial on immigration brought to the surface (“Ending illegal entry,” Aug. 2).
It is naive to believe nobody benefited from the entry of immigrants into this country. If so, they never would have been allowed to enter.
If it were not in the self-interest of the powers that be to have low-wage workers in this country, this situation never would have presented itself.
It’s probably hypocritical at best that, when the general perception becomes that these people are no longer of use to this country, we cast aside a whole generation, or two, of immigrants who have made the United States their home.
It’s important to consider that, although it was not all of our doing, we played a lead role in the situation at hand. It’s also important to consider that laws are supposed to reflect the moral imperative of the land and, in this case, they don’t.
We cannot, in good conscience, say, on one hand, “Work for us,” and on the other, “Don’t be human. Do not bring with you the weary or the tired. Do not misbehave, for we will hold the many accountable for the few.”
More importantly, we shouldn’t say, “We are done with you. Go back to where you came from because you have become more trouble than you are worth.”
When we say that, we are creating the environment of hate for which we condemn other countries.
I also believe it is a fallacy that, because many of us advocate for immigration reform, that we, somehow, do not wish safety in our streets or for criminals to be held accountable. One issue does not void the other. It is not all or nothing.
Comprehensive immigration reform must reflect reality. And, until these laws are reformed, we will continue to separate families and send youth back to countries they did not envision in their futures. These individuals did a job well, were not a drain on our social services, created family and were a part of our community.
It’s sad that it should be OK not to address these issues with some semblance of compassion.
The writer is a health educator who lives in Greensboro.