News-Record.com

The North Carolina Piedmont Triad's top go-to source for News
A service of the News & Record, Greensboro, North Carolina

Home

Capital Beat

« And so it begins | Main | Betting on the lottery »

Alston-Barber race

I will post a link to my story on the race for NAACP president between Melvin "Skip" Alston of Greensboro and the Rev. William Barber of Goldsboro when I get a chance. However, there's a little box on the story directing readers here to discuss, and I wanted to make sure there was a thread for them to use.

(Update: Click here for the story.)

I've been calling around on this story for a few weeks and waited to write it until I could visit with both men in person. In the mean time, there has been other coverage.

This story from the N&O (registration required) has gotten some notice, although Alston complained to me that it was unbalance. I think it was pretty fair myself. I would differ with the characterization that it is rare to have a contest for NAACP president. There's an election every two years and Alston has had challengers in the past. But that's a small point.

There's also been some written by bloggers, although most that I've seen seems to be clearly in the pro-Barber or anti-Skip camp. Find examples and more links at Floyd's place, the political agitator, and Hoggard's.

I didn't do a lot of horse-race fashion analyzing in my story for a couple reasons. Chief among them I had the persistent feeling that folks I were talking to were holding back. That was particularly so in the case of people who might cast a ballot on Saturday, who sometimes talked about the person they were backing but would say nothing about the other candidate, good, bad or indifferent.

That leads neatly to my second reservation: the vote will be a sampling of the membership by way of delegates, not a poll of the entire membership. That restricts the sample size and allows for goofy numerical stuff to happen.

And finally, this is a private organization selecting its leadership. I can't claim to have a real thorough knowledge of how this process works or its quirks.

That said, both men can point to signs in their favor and at least one big challenge.

Barber certainly has a lot of grass roots buzz and a lot of people talking about him throughout the state. He's traveled widely as a speaker, is known from his days working in the state bureaucracy and is a minister of a pretty well known congregation. The question for Barber is whether he can convert that grass roots zeal into votes, since it will be delegates selected by each branch who make the choice.

Without having real intimate knowledge of the group, I would have to imagine the delegate system favors Alston, the long time incumbent. One of the president's main jobs is to help build local chapters and lend support in time of need. That gives Alston a tremendous amount of exposure to the people making decisions on delegates. Alston can also point to his seat on the NAACP's national board and several awards that he and the state conference have one this year from the national group. Still, there seems to be a pretty vocal "anyone-but-skip" faction out there, and that's never a good sign for a candidate in any office.

Of course, some folks might wonder why it would matter to non NAACP members who the president of the group is.

Firstly, the post of state NAACP president gives one a tremendous bully pulpit to speak out on matters of public concern. That person is frequently a go-to quote for us scrubby media types and can generate a lot of attention on any issue they choose to raise.

Second, that person has a tremendous amount of access to politicians at the federal, state and local strata and can bring a lot of political pressure to get here way. Working in the name of the NAACP allows its president to nudge state policy this way and that.

The convention starts up Thursday down out the Koury Convention Center and the schedule I have says it winds up Saturday night, although folks have told me there might be an informal Sunday event or two. We should get word on the president's race Saturday afternoon or evening.

Comments (3)

To report abuse of the comment feature on this site, please use the feedback form at the bottom of any page.

Don't understand how you figure the delegate system favors Skip? Could you tell me how you came up with that? Are you saying Skip has built chapters and has helped local chapter when in need?

Awards don't mean anything in some cases because sometimes awards are given out in a buddy system fashion.

Mark Binker said:

(Appologies if this answer shows up twice...I answered before and it didn't seem to take.)

Curmilus:

Remember, I'm an outsider looking in. I don't know this system real well, but I would say yes, generally, the system of delegates seems to favor incumbents in general and Alston in specific.

Any involvement Alston has had in building up chapters may have helped. Also, Alston has been involved in lending aid or support to chapters involved in public disputes. That simply gives him a lot of contact with folks in those chapters who are likely to become delegates. If they think he's done well by them, or that they owe him a favor, I'd have to think they'd be more likely to vote for him.

Also, having covered politics at some level in Guilford County (where Alston is a commissioner) for the better part of the past five years and Alston's board of commissioners for some of that time, I've seen Alston work the rules of whatever system he was in to his advantage. I would be surprised if Alston was not already "counting noses" to make sure he had the vote on Saturday.

Even if the awards don't mean much in and of themselves, what do they say about Alston's connections across the state and across the country. Wouldn't having a lot of "buddies" portend well for him?

Again, I don't know the system real well. There could be things going on that I'm completely missing. But I learned a long time ago that you do not declare a winner before a contest (espeically a political contest) is finished.

curmilus said:

I understand you are an outsider looking in and that is why I responded. If the responses that I am receiving go as plan, I feel strongly that Dr. Barber will be able to declare victory on Saturday.

At the present moment my resources tell me that only 52 branches out of 109 are active. Sources say Skip recently sent out letters asking branches to call him if they wanted him to appear to help with their membership. I have talked to several branches and individuals/groups who didn't get any support from Alston when they have called on him in the past.

I think this is going to be a little different from Commissioners board. I am quite sure Skip has counted noses because that is something any candidate in any kind of election should do.

Some awards are done behind closed doors as well just like other things. A couple of folks on a committee can mess up somethings if they want to. It is just like the branch of the year and the president of the year award I understand was lead by Skip's righthand Fred Yates. I can't wait to see how others respond when the announcement is made. It happens often that some awards do not meet the description of why the person/organization that receives it.

I totally agree with your statement as follows: "But I learned a long time ago that you do not declare a winner before a contest (espeically a political contest) is finished."

Post a comment

Users who post comments to this blog tacitly agree to observe the News & Record Online Service Terms of Use and Content Submission Agreement. Comments which do not adhere to the terms of this agreement may be removed and the submitter may be banned from further participation. Please use the feedback form at the bottom of any page to report abuse of this feature.

Explore This Blog

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Search

Channels
Font Size
Tools
Question, Comment or Suggestion? Please contact us.

News & Record and NRinteractive

200 E. Market Street, Greensboro, NC 27401 (336) 373-7000 (800) 553-6880
1813 N. Main Street, High Point, NC 27262 (336) 883-4422
203 E. Harris Place, Eden, NC 27288 (336) 627-1781
4213 S. Church Street, Burlington, NC 27215 (336) 449-7064

Copyright (C) 2008 News & Record and Landmark Communications, Inc.