Several people have written since Wednesday morning advocating that President Bush's victory sends the newspaper a message that we should reflect the voters' political preferences. Here's part of an e-mail sent to Allen Johnson, our editorial page editor:
"You claim to be a part of this town/community but your endorsements (president) do not seem to reflect how North Carolina and Greensboro vote!!!"
For the record, John Kerry won in Guilford County.
I've written about this idea that the newspaper should reflect the community in our news coverage before. But because I don't have anything to do with our editorial pages or our endorsements, I haven't touched on those. And the editorial pages have an entirely different mission. I asked Allen about that:
"We don't consider our endorsements an attempt to predict how our readers will vote. Whether our picks win or lose doesn't matter to us nearly as much as whether we feel we made informed, principled decisions. That's why we personally interview the candidates in the vast majority of races we endorse in. And it's why we sometimes make choices that the majority of our readers might even vehemently disagree with.
"When, for instance, the old Greensboro Daily News championed the cause of integrated public facilities, many of our readers disagreed. But the editors still felt it was the right call. Similarly, we respect our readers' ability to make up their own minds about their personal choices. And we don't presume to have the power to make the masses vote a certain way. We just hope they'll vote, period, whether they like our endorsements or not."
He sent this along:
"Here's how our endorsements squared with this year's results in Guilford County:
N&R pick _______________Guilford results
John Kerry ____________John Kerry
Mike Easley ____________Mike Easley
Erskine Bowles _________Erskine Bowles
Steve Troxler __________Steve Troxler
Howard Coble __________Howard Coble
Mel Watt ______________Mel Watt
Brad Miller _____________Brad Miller
Jim Snyder _____________Beverly Perdue
Ralph Campbell__________Ralph Campbell
Jim Long _______________Jim Long
Wayne Goodwin _________Wayne Goodwin
Bill Fletcher ____________June Atkinson
Richard Moore __________Richard Moore
Kay Hagan ______________Kay Hagan
Pricey Harrison _________Pricey Harrison
Maggie Jeffus___________Maggie Jeffus
Alma Adams _____________Alma Adams
Jeff Thigpen ___________Jeff Thigpen
Roger Cotten ___________Paul Gibson
Trudy Wade _____________Trudy Wade
Kirk Perkins ____________Kirk Perkins
Mike Barber _____________Mike Winstead
Sarah Parker ____________Sarah Parker
Jim Wynn _______________Rachel Lea Hunter
Linda McGee ____________Linda McGee
Wanda Bryant ___________Wanda Bryant
Alan Thornburg__________Barbara Jackson
Tom Foster _____________Linda Falls
Robby Hassell __________Robby Hassell
Susan Bray _____________Susan Bray
Susan Burch ____________Susan Burch
Patrice Hinnant ________Patrice Hinnant
Sherry Alloway _________Sherry Alloway
Dot Kearns _____________Dot Kearns
William Fails ___________Walter Childs
Kris Cooke _____________Kris Cooke
Amos Quick _____________Amos Quick
For all amendments ______For all amendments
For parks bonds _________For parks bonds
For GTCC bonds __________For GTCC bonds
For all HP bonds ________For all HP bonds
"Total: Out of 50 endorsements in contested races, Guilford voters agreed with the News & Record on 38, and disagreed with us on 12, including three cases in which we endorsed Republicans."