Weather stories must die*
For a couple years now, I've been half-heartedly discouraging editors from doing much in the newspaper with stories about impending weather. Are we telling readers anything they don't already know? TV and online have won that battle and newspapers have lost. I doubt many people look to the paper for a prediction about an approaching storm when the blanket "team" coverage is ubiquitous -- and more timely -- on television and the Internet.
Ever since I've been in this business, reporters have hated writing weather stories, primarily because they seem so silly and predictable. When we were at the News & Observer, Howard Troxler wrote an "impending storm" story as if it were an investigative piece, full of skulduggery and secret sources at the weather bureau. It was bounced back to him by a dour and unappreciative editor. Twenty five years later, here comes Meranda: Raise your hand if you hate writing weather stories....It's like writing about traffic lights changing colors. Everyone knows it's going to happen, and they can kind of figure out for themselves what comes next.
We try to write them compellingly, but there are only so many ways to write an interesting weather story and an armless man can count them on his fingers. No, that's harsh. There are a couple ways, but not many. To put it another way, how many times do you need to see a TV reporter standing by the side of the road with a yardstick preparing to measure the inch of snow that's fallen and hear her tell you not to drive if you don't have to?
Deepening the issue is that, despite meteorologists' boasts about accuracy, weather predictions are notoriously wrong. Last night the forecast was for it to be snowing right at this minute. Not happening. It's 38 degrees.
But it's a newspaper tradition that's hard to shake. As the storm approaches, it becomes what people talk about. Schools let out. Businesses close. How can a newspaper not write about it? Besides, with everything focused on a snow storm there isn't much else going on to write about.
* We need to log the coming storm in the paper in a small way somewhere, but it's an online story. Now, after the storm hits and power is knocked out, schools are closed and life is changed, then that's a different story.
Comments (7)
To report abuse of the comment feature on this site, please use the feedback form at the bottom of any page.
Once I filed a weather story that was sort of like a play. It took place at the breakfast table of a typical family, and members were sitting around discussing the pending weather event. While I wouldn't describe the editors' response as dour (at least not in a way that could ever be traced back to me), there was considerable head-scratching before they busted it in favor of a more traditional story. There's a better than even chance that I just didn't pull of what I'd attempted.
But I'm gonna give the mock investigative piece a try next time I draw the short straw!
Posted on January 19, 2008 10:46 AM
My goal is that you never do a traditional one again.
Posted on January 19, 2008 12:44 PM
Weather is like sports. Somebody wins, somebody loses, and they'll always play another game.
Then there's this:
http://www.goldensnowball.com/
Posted on January 19, 2008 4:31 PM
Is that why todays paper had an editorial about today's snow?
Posted on January 19, 2008 6:18 PM
Is that why todays paper had an editorial about today's snow?
Posted on January 19, 2008 6:18 PM
I don't know why the editorial folks wrote about snow -- I am not part of that group -- but it doesn't contradict my point.
Posted on January 19, 2008 7:35 PM
The problem with weather stories isn't the topic. It's the form.
No one wants to write, edit or read the "snow is coming" roundup of 25 paragraphs of text (with a photo of "local man" buying bread and milk) because it's been done a million times. If reporters are tired of that story, you know your readers are. Yet weather is a local story that people care about.
Instead of the expected approach, find a new angle and present it differently. Try a checklist, a Q&A or another format. Apply the techniques you used with the effective MLK package (text, slideshow and video) to other recurring stories, including the weather, commencements, council meetings, etc.
Posted on January 21, 2008 1:09 PM