It's all in fun.... Really!
The "In and Out" list this morning required knowledge of pop culture, a sense of humor and, in some cases, a thick skin. As these things go, then, we got some quick and negative feedback.
Some excerpts of e-mails I've gotten:
When "16 and pregnant" is considered IN, it is no longer fun. It is in fact thoughtless, irresponsible, glamorizes teen pregnancy, and certainly sends the wrong message to families in general and teens specifically.
I cannot share this article with my daughter because it is hard enough to explain why a girl (emphasis on girl, not woman) should not get pregnant, nor should she be experimenting with sex, at 16. It may be a fact of our society that this happens, but that is not the lesson in our family.
Further down your list you write that FedEx is OUT and HondaJet is IN. While this is certainly less harmful than the reference to a pregnant 16 year old, it is an irresponsible comment probably done for cheap shock value. At least the people at FedEx are adults and will recognize the comment for what it is -- one person's uninformed opinion. FedEx will bring many sorely needed jobs and much revenue to the Triad. It may even have influenced, in some way, HondaJet's decision to settle here. To do anything short of welcoming FedEx with open arms is short-sighted and, once again, irresponsible. This goes for any company coming to the Triad.
The "16 and pregnant," obviously referring to the Spears' sisters, came from the original Washington Post list. We added the offensive FedEx-HondaJet item.
*****************************
I am Mormon and am very disappointed in what you published on D1 today in the "Out or In" article. I am referring to the second item in the vertical column, which notes that "Mormon undergarments" are "out" and "Spanx" are "in."
I am hurt that you have blasphemed such a private, sacred matter and am disappointed that religious bigotry is alive and well in my hometown newspaper.
This one also came from The Washington Post's original list. I admit I don't even know what Spanx are.
*****************************
I see your team couldn't resist another shot at cheering for a move of the tourney to Sedgefield as part of the "In/Out list." Of course, according to their story last week there has been no decision made. I don't really expect your reporters to do much work in digging out facts but it isn’t hard to find out what is going on at Forest Oaks.
Because we continue to track the efforts to move the Wyndham from Forest Oaks to Sedgefield, everytime we write about it we get letters saying that we're biased.
****************************
These lists are designed to engender debate and discussion and maybe a few laughs. They aren't editorial policy, endorsements or words to live by. (I know they aren't all funny. Written word humor is always a matter of taste.) Not surprisingly, Ed gets it and gives the list all the respect it deserves.
Comments (6)
To report abuse of the comment feature on this site, please use the feedback form at the bottom of any page.
Between Britney Spears' sister and the popular success of "Juno" I think it's fairly obvious the "16 and pregnant" thing was a zeitgeist-y joke.
But hey, if your kid is old enough to read and be interested in the newspaper it may be time you talked to them about why kids get pregnant at 16 and what your stance on that is. Before...you know...you HAVE to have that conversation.
Posted on January 11, 2008 3:01 PM
Served no purpose and was in poor taste.
Posted on January 11, 2008 6:00 PM
Rock Paper Scissors will never be "OUT" as long as two or more grown-ups have disagreements resolve. Your suggested replacement, nevertheless, may prove useful if it ever gains popularity - you walk into a board meeting with a six-foot cardboard tube in your hand and people know you mean business.
Posted on January 11, 2008 7:52 PM
The man said a knowledge of pop culture, a sense of humor and a thick skin, Tony. Lighten up and don't be so politically correct.
Posted on January 11, 2008 8:15 PM
Sweet Mother of God, people take this stuff too seriously. If they're offended by that, may they never ride with me in my news car...
Posted on January 11, 2008 11:06 PM
"I cannot share this article with my daughter because it is hard enough to explain why a girl (emphasis on girl, not woman) should not get pregnant, nor should she be experimenting with sex, at 16."
I dunno about you, but I think it's pretty easy to explain why a girl shouldn't get pregnant or have sex at 16. I'm guessing what some parents find difficult is actually having that conversation.
What was it Dave Barry said about needing closed captioning for the humor-impaired? I think it could be put to good use here.
Also, I'd just like to point out that this list made me feel extremely old. I'm only 28, and I didn't get a bunch of the references. (I do, however, own a pair of Spanx tights.)
Posted on January 13, 2008 12:44 AM