The following is a Counterpoint column.
By Beverly Meredith
The young gay and lesbian patriots who were arrested at a Greensboro military recruiting center are to be commended for their courage. They stood up to the unjust and discriminatory "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" law.
Many soldiers believe that it is a privilege to put their lives on the line in service of this country and its principles. By that extraordinary commitment, the soldier declares that those founding principles are utterly more important than the life that he or she may lose in their defense.
It should be humbling for a society that, through the very denial of enlistment to openly gay and lesbian soldiers, has to face the unfairness of a law that strays so far from our country's character and is so undeserving of any soldier's sacrifice. There have always been gays in the military, and there will continue to be, but to wink and pretend otherwise dishonors their service.
We are a great country, but we are not perfect. We must honestly ask ourselves why we would deny rights of service, as well as other civil rights to men and women simply because of sexual orientation. There is no shame in homosexuality, only in the requirement that it be kept a secret. That goes for civil life as well, but can be particularly poignant when we consider our gay and lesbian service people. Are we comfortable as a country, asking young men and women to forgo their rights, while they embrace the privilege of defending ours? Even to the point of sacrificing their lives?
The only shame here is in a country that does not live up to its potential of justice and equality for all.
We have made similar mistakes in our military history — the segregation of black soldiers up through World War II and the absence of recognition of the services that they provided. We realize the injustice now and are a better country for it. The military subsequently worked hard to integrate soldiers and to become an example of institutional equality. Becoming a better country often requires us to look ourselves in the mirror and see where we could be better, and to recognize injustice when we see it.
We may be a great country, but we are not finished. Thank you, Matt, Jessica, Stacey and Alex, for holding up the mirror and reminding us that there is still work to do.
The writer lives in Liberty.


Comments (6)
Beverly,
I agree. The Army should have inducted them and let them join their unit in Irag or Afganistan. Matt, Jessica, Stacey and Alex should be granted their wish to serve their country, and they would have learned what that really means. They really don't get any praises for holding up a mirror. Praises go to those that actually go and serve their country.
Posted by Oak Ridge Runner
|
October 7, 2006 9:12 AM
Oh, Beverly. If you really want to write a letter and thank someone for their service to his country, thank Bobby Callahan. He is deserving of thanks. He was a true patriot.
Posted by Oak Ridge Runner
|
October 7, 2006 9:15 AM
Ms. Meredith, thanks for writing a letter that the detractors especially need to read/hear!
It is criminal to not allow equal access to any citizen! While I am a pacifist, I see the inherent right of anyone who so chooses to join the military. While I oppose all war, if someone chooses to join the military, I have to respect the right of that person to choose, even if I disagree.
The reason that I do this is because I believe in the equality of ALL humans, regardless of the situation/circumstance. In the eyes of God, all humans are equal, why not in a country that declares, "...all [humans] are created equal....?"
Shalom
Posted by Darryl
|
October 7, 2006 1:27 PM
Seems to me, if the military will take in a Lindy England, they damn sure ought not to be kicking out the linguists and interpreters just because they were gay!
Posted by DemonDeacon
|
October 7, 2006 11:43 PM
Guess everyone's just lining up to go to Iraq!
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/15176088/
That is, since everything is just peachy over there. You know, with the "PLAN" that the President has.....
Posted by DemonDeacon
|
October 8, 2006 8:26 PM
And yet, the thing is that is the GLBT people are so bad, what better way to get rid of them?
Or is it that there is a fear that the GLBT people may "one-up" the hetero folks? We all know that would not be acceptable!
Shalom
Posted by Darryl
|
October 8, 2006 8:58 PM