News & Record, Greensboro, NC
,
°
Humidity: %
Wind: mph,
Market Place
TriadCareers TriadCars TriadHomes Triad Marketplace Business Directory Classifieds Newspaper Ads Featured Job Ads Archives Apartments Celebrations Obituaries Place an Ad Personals Print Advertising Ad Post Online Advertising N&R Store
ADVERTISEMENT
Special Sections
test
Letters to the Editor
Friday, March 30, 2007

« Community's support led to successful rescue | Main | Rewarding wayward behavior is unwise »

Accountability leads to forgiveness

The following is a Counterpoint:

By George and Pat Gates

"Responsibility, n. A detachable burden easily shifted to the shoulders of God, Fate, Fortune, Luck or one's neighbor. In the days of astrology it was customary to unload it upon a star."
— Ambrose Bierce

Our son Stephen was killed by a hit-and-run driver. A legal loophole, subsequently closed, made it possible for the perpetrators to escape accountability. So, we've had good reason to think long and often — obsess, maybe — about accountability.

After reading "Anchor Speaks About Accident" and repeatedly watching the video released by Tolly Carr's lawyer, we are moved to respond.

By all accounts, Tolly Carr has been an admirable young man. He appears remorseful; but, unfortunately, it seems most about his own fall from "prince to pauper."

He seems to accept no accountability for what he did to someone else, but rather laments that his life has been devastated. As much as that is true — and we are saddened by that fact — we hope he can learn a different expression of sorrow.

We know, from the victim's side, how the family of Casey Bokhoven must feel after seeing that video. We heard similar "apologies" after our son's death from those involved: sorrow for our loss, sorrow for the anguish visited on their lives, and most distressing, sorrow that this event had "happened," somehow independent of their own decisions and actions.

Perhaps it is unintended, or perhaps he's been legally advised to be cautious. Either way, Carr's words are an inadequate gesture. He asked for prayers that the Bokhoven family might get over their anger.

His kind of apology will likely make them more angry, and justifiably so. The only satisfactory apology is one that acknowledges accountability: "I'm sorry for the choices I did or did not make, for the actions I did or did not take, for the awful thing I did to you." Those are words quite different from, "I'm sorry for your loss; I'm sorry that you're angry; I'm sorry my own life has been ruined."

We do not wish ill of Mr. Carr. No good ever comes from vengeance. We do hope he realizes this important difference. Things can be responsible: a tornado, a star falling from the sky, even a swerving car.

But only people can elect to be accountable. People with the moral courage to say, for good or ill, "I did this, and I am sorry for what it caused."

We hope that Tolly Carr, a good and decent man, will find that courage. And, we pray that the Bokhoven family might accept that as a first step on their long road to forgiveness.

The writers live in Greensboro.


Comments (5)

An EXCELLENT Counterpoint written by a couple who had to work for justice in the case of their late son! Hopefully the day will come that Tolly Carr will hiimself express honest and truthful remorse for his careless action of drinking and driving; which took the life of an innocent person.

Shalom

As one who lost a lot of physical ability as a result of being hit head-on by a drunk driver (with six prior DWI's) and having my dad killed by a drunk driver, I can personally attest to the difficulty in forgiveness. At present, I have achieved only neutrality. I do not dwell on making myself strive to forgive. It simply does not enter my mind except when it is brought up. Then I seek that neutral state.

Had I or my father been hit by accident, it would have been easier to forgive. But both these men were habitual drunks who thought so little of anyone other than themselves that they got behind the wheel of a 2500 pound weapon. It was a deliberate action by them to do this. Then after doing their damage, they hire scumbag lawyers to try to avoid accepting responsibility/accountability.

Praying that they learn something and make the effort to change their irresponsible behavior is as all the time I personally want to give these men.

This is an exceptionally good lte. Thank you, George and Pat Gates.

Great letter.

The only thing I've seen Tolly do is speak at a church in an effort to get money for his defense. Pretty shameful, IMO.

Everyone makes mistakes. Sometimes they are fatal. However, they need to own up to them.

In cases like Yvonnes, with repeat offenders, there is no excuse. These folks should have their arms removed to prevent them from drinking OR driving.

as i see it, tolly carr isnt special enough for me to want to see what happens to him when he gets out of jail. he'll mostly get a civil suit for millions against him also. he needs all the money he can get. but even then, isnt it useless? will bokhoven's family really forgive him? Will he get his job back as anchor? or even just as a reporter covering local dog shows? I think not. He's going to have to move to wyoming for a fresh start.

Post a comment

Contact Us | About Us | News & Record Jobs | Terms of Use | Subscribe | Help
Print Advertising | Online Advertising | © 2004 News & Record
Subscription Services, Manage your subscription, Create a subscription

ADVERTISEMENT