Here were my thoughts on last night's "American Idol" as the singers performed:
Paris Bennett - I wouldn't have gone with such a dated song as Gloria Estefan, but she'll move on.
Lisa Tucker - To put it simply - see you in the top 12.
Melissa McGhee - Tell us about car racing, because that's what we want in an Idol. Oh, and the 80s called, they want your ripped jeans back. Did I actually see her do the Roger Rabbit dance at one point?
Kinnik Sky - Was she singing? All I can think about it pig intestines now. Thanks. Whoops - she hit a few bad notes. She's gone.
Katharine McPhee - This is the first time I can remember what she sang. She just jumped a couple spots on my list. Probably the best of the night in my opinion.
Ayla Brown - She picked a good, modern song, but has a weak vocal performance. Stop pointing at the camera, that's not nice. She's only 17? I thought she was in her mid-20s. She needs to relax and have more fun.
Mandisa - How can someone suck their thumb until they were in their mid-20s? Good performance. Send the thumbsucker to the next round!
Kellie Pickler - Again, her sad story and strong voice are her ticket to the top 12. Though she called herself a "mink" and pronounced the 'l' in salmon... Her ignorant country girl routine could get old fast. She's starting to come across like Jessica Simpson.
On the bubble: Melissa "Roger Rabbit" McGhee, Kinnik Sky, Ayla Brown
Posted by jeffhahnedisabled at March 8, 2006 7:23 AM
