Blake Lewis - Wow. 311?! An interesting choice, and a risk, but I think it worked for his funky style. I can't believe it took five seasons and change for someone to finally take a more modern approach. It wasn't a vocal showcase, but it was fun. He showed that you don't have to be boring.

Coming up, John Mayer and Pearl Jam? Wow - I'm shocked.

Sanjaya Malakar - OK, I'm kind of scared that he hulas. It was a good song choice, but his vocals aren't getting any better. How has he lasted this long? Three bad weeks in a row, this guy's gotta go. He lacked any soul for the song. This year's "Guy Smiey" should be on his way out.

Sundance Head - I thought it was the wrong tone for "Jeremy." He gave it kind of a pop tone instead of a rock one and it didn't work for me. I thought it was pretty bad.

Chris Richardson - I didn't like a ballad for him, but it was a good contrast against the first three.

Jared Cotter - He gave a solid performance. Every time I see him though, I can't help but think, "Welcome back, Mr. Cot-ter!" He just looked a little too cheesy at times tonight.

Brandon Rogers - A nice, hip funky tune that fit his vocal well.

Phil Stacey - His voice sounds awful in the low tones. Yikes, I thought it was a joke at first. It picked up, but still wasn't great. I thought it was pitchy and just all over the place. It was a risk that didn't work.

Chris Sligh - A solid performance as usual. No big surprise here.

Bottom three - Sanjaya, Phil and Sundance