Whatever happened to Bush on legacy preferences?
When I heard President Bush in person last summer tell minority journalists that he'd have had a snowball's chance of getting into Yale without legacy admissions -- and that he thought such preferences, often for the rich or at least the very well-off, were unfair -- I flatly predicted that this would be the last we'd hear of this subject from the Oval Office.
Boy was I right.
Pressed in August by journalist Roland S. Martin on the issue at the Unity Convention of black, Asian, Native American and Hispanic reporters and editors in Washington, Bush said yes,something ought to be done about legacy preferences. And in light of the administration's stance against what it charged was preferential treatment in admissions for minorities to the University of Michigan Law School, the president was hard-pressed to say much else.
"In my case, I had to knock on a lot of doors to follow the old man," the president quipped as he squirmed around the circumstances of his own wink-and-nod college admission.
So far as I can tell, he never mentioned the topic again.
For the record, here are some realities about legacy admissions, according to The Wall Street Journal:
1. Five Supreme Court justices or their children have qualified for legacy preferences.
2. Legacy preferences overwhelmingly benefit whites.
3. Legacy admissions account for between 10 percent to 15 percent of students at most Ivy League schools and enjoy much higher rates of acceptance than other applicants. At Harvard,40 percent of legacy applicants were enrolled in 2003 versus 11 percent of applicants overall. Princeton took 35 percent of alumni children, as compared to 11 percent of overall applicants. The University of Pennsylvania accepted 41 percent of legacies, compared versus 21 percent of applicants overall.
4. Legacy admissions are allowed to keep alumni (read: well-heeled donors) happy, even at taxpayer-supported state schools.
But racial minorities remain a favorite scapegoat and target when charges of preferences fly (from college admissions to newspaper hiring). Go figure.