News-Record.com

The North Carolina Piedmont Triad's top go-to source for News
A service of the News & Record, Greensboro, North Carolina

Home

Thinking Out Loud

« One door closes .... | Main | This week's column »

Grimsley's choice

Following a blistering protest by some parents, Grimsley High School has abandoned plans to create a ninth-grade academy.

The episode offers several lessons, among them:

1. The tension between the haves and have-nots in our schools. The program would have addressed underachievers, but some parents worried about the impact it would have had on the achievers. I'm not convinced the achievers would have suffered.

2. Money talks. The academy would have been funded with a federal grant. Now the school will consider other options to address the high failure rate among ninth-graders. How to pay for it remains unclear.

3. The disgruntled parents say they share concern for the struggling students. I hope these parents are equally engaged in finding new solutions as opposing the old one.

4. Communication was a big problem. The outcome might have been different if parents had been apprised of the plan from the start.

Comments (13)

To report abuse of the comment feature on this site, please use the feedback form at the bottom of any page.

teacher said:

Grimsley will still be seeking a "Small Communities Grant."

So, if you worry that they will NOT be getting the money that the "Academy" would have brought, they most likely will still get it.

So, underachievers will STILL be addressed and the money will be there to back it up. It will just go by a different name and have a different approach then academies.

Do you think Grier would have left this decision up to the principals/parents at the risk of losing the grant money? NO. Grier never says no to a grant.

Allen Johnson said:

Thanks for your comment. You are right. The schools will pursue what appears to be a viable Plan B (if they get the funding). But the undercurrents of distrust are so strong that I worry about any option succeeding at this point.
The ongoing thread of comments on the Chalkboard speak to the tension and discord out there, especially from parents in High Point, who perceive a double standard in how the school system handles such matters. Is there any credence to that? I have heard precious few High Point parents come forward to defend what is happening there with the Choice Plan. Are they out there?
My colleague Doug Clark is a longtime High Point resident and an avid supporter of the schools there. At the risk of putting him on the spot, I wonder his take on the High Point-Greensboro comparisons running hot and heavy on the Chalkboard.

Buckmtn said:

Allen, the double standard is more than perception it's a reality. My family is fortunate that if this cherade of a lottery does not work out next month, that Private School is an affordable altnernative.

I am certain that the residents of High Point appreciate the article on Private Schools that was in the HP section of the N&R today. Trust me that it kills me to even talk about private schools having grown up in very diverse public school system in metropolitan NYC where white was the minority.

However if it is the goal of Ms. Kearns and her puppet Ms. Mendenhall to have the HP schools at 100% free and reduced lunches then my family is prepared to do what it can to help them achieve this goal. The only thing I'm sorry for is that education vouchers are not yet a reality.

I would hope that you would be interested in a spokesperson on this matter that either lives off of Skeet Club Rd, Penny Rd, or Guilford College Rd. I believe you'll find 1000's of people who can compose sentences as well as any one on the other side of Main Street in High Point. And for that part care just as much as about all of the schools of Guilford County.

Sorry in advance for the tirade, but you touched a nerve when you offered up another spokesperson. I thought that was supposed to be Ms. Kearns and Ms. Mendhenhall, however that did not work out to well over the past 15 months.

I am sure that Mr. Clark is a nice person and I would be glad to meet him. I assure you that nothing I have said is directed towards him.

Melanie Rodenbough said:

Re: Allen Johnson's 4 lessons learned:
1) Lots of parents of lots of different kinds of kids opposed the 9th grade academy at Grimsley. Interesting that Allen attributes the disagreement to the "have's" vs. the "have-nots." Perhaps he'd care to speak w/ the mom of a child coming to Grimsley for the lifeskills classes who was afraid her child would be shortchanged by the academy, or the poor grandmother who came to the parent forum even though she was not comfortable speaking out about her disapproval of the 9th grade academy when the rest of us were "using all those big words." When you try to reduce a substantive disagreement to a simple formula you miss a lot of people who don't fit your pre-conceived ideas. Polarizing a community with simplistic labels is an easy way to respond to criticism or disagreement that avoids the uncomfortable work of trying to listen and understand what folks are actually saying. Grimsely parents opposed the 9th grade academy for lots of reasons, one of them being that it seemed to us to be the wrong remedy for the problems our kids are having. The literature about 9th grade academies talks a lot about 9th graders havng trouble with the transition to high school, but the problem that was identified at Grimsley was that we have many kids failing and dropping out who have struggled in school for years. How is that a transition problem? Moreover, the solution we were looking at held very little promise for our struggling students: just putting kids on teams (just like they've been on and failed with for the 3 previous years in middle school)seemed to us to hold very little promise of educating those kids. When you are a 16 year old reading on a 2nd grade level what you need is serious, focused, just about one-on-one intervention with a good reading teacher. Would the grant provide that? No. The grant does not pay for teachers. There is no magic in a 9th grade academy; it is the content of what the school does that might make a difference in a kid's life, not the structure of the school.
It is true that completely breaking up large urban high schools into academies or smaller learning communities holds some promise for those totally failing high schools, and it is those schools (in Baltimore, NYC, Philadelphia, etc.)that are the subject of many of the SLC studies.
Again, we just didn't think that was what Grimsley needed.
On a personal level, I love it when people who don't know me from Adam dismiss me as a "have" as opposed to a "have not." It's been a long road from the children's home where I grew up, but I am grateful indeed to now be included with the "have's." I just also happen to think the "have-nots" deserve to have some real effort made to give them the one ticket out of one category and into the other, the ticket that made all the difference in the world for me: an education.
2) I don't quite understand Allen's "money talks" lesson. The small learning communities grant in the High Point schools is going to fund a lot of consultant hours, as well as travel and sub pay for teachers. It does look like it will put some materials in the classrooms also. But it won't pay for teachers, and teachers are the most powerful and important piece of education. So how important is the extra grant money, and at what cost does it come? Personally, I'd rather hear some real leadership talking around here than money doing the talking.
3)Now we parents have gone from being "have's" to "disgruntled parents!" (How about "thinking parents?") Yes, we all need to be engaged in finding solutions, because there aren't a lot of them out there, are there? If it were easy to fix the problems of students who fail and drop out, I believe some of our excellent administrators and teachers and ministers and other community leaders would have already done just that. Many parents at Grimsley and elsewhere would want to be part of those solutions, but are increasingly getting the message that their concerns about their own children are not recognized as legitimate or worthy of concern. Here's a novel idea: Those of us who seek answers might do well to work to bring parents from different backgrounds together around what unites them, as opposed to driving them apart based upon their differences. .
4)Communication wasn't the problem so much as the process was the problem at Grimsley. The administration knew last summer that we had received this grant to study smaller learning communities. The grant calls for the whole school community to be involved in any plans to restrucure the school -- parents, students, teachers and even the outside community. Yet nothing was said about the SLC grant or its implications until late December, when a small committee was chosen (not elected)to come up with what turned out to be a pre-determined remedy for the school: the 9th grade academy. The process called for very little real opportunity for input from the school community because the time was too short. Faculty members felt they were not being listened to, and most parents as well as students knew absolutely nothing about it. Then we found out, after finally obtaining a copy of the grant we were unwittingly working toward satisfying, that the 9th grade academy was only the beginning: if we wanted in the grant, we had to come up with a plan to put the whole school into smaller learning communities by the end of the grant period. As the experience in High Point shows, it's no problem for the central administration to come up with ways to re-design schools without much input from anyone - but we didn't think that should happen again. The Grimsley proces was antithetical to what the grant speaks of as necessary and vital to the school reform's success -- having a school community involved and supportive. If recognizing that makes me disgruntled, then I'll cheefully plead guilty.
And of course, "teacher" may be right in the end.

Teddy Ballgame said:

As I read Mr. Johnson's original remarks and then, Ms. Rodenbough's response, it strikes me that these same words could have been written one year ago when the High Point Choice Plan/Lottery was being debated. As Yogi Berra would say, "It's deja vu all over again".

Terry Grier and the School Board are still running amok, finding and implementing new and innovative solutions to the wrong problems, seeking to get federal grant money to fund their unneeded and unwanted programs, parents expressing concerns about the solutions being implemented without their knowledge and involvement, and blaming the lack of communication for bad outcomes. It appears that nothing really changes when it comes to the subject of public education in Guilford County. And, this is what we the citizens pay a tidy sum in taxes each year to enjoy? Is there any doubt why the business of private education is flowering in this county? Oh, if we only had a few more viable charter schools to provide some additional competition for these people. But, the reasons for the paucity of charter school options in North Carolina is another subject for another day. Perhaps, the News-Record would like to do an expose on this problem someday as to why we have such limited charter school opportunities in the Old North State, which I understand is limited to 100 statewide.

Barbara Ann said:

Melanie,

Your comments about "polarizing a community" really hit home.

They tried that number on all the good folks at SW last year. You wouldn't believe where a lot of these inuendos started. It is so easy to mislabel people just to keep the pot stirred.

People know the truth; good, honest, hardworking parents who want the best for their kids. That is nothing to be ashamed of. That best is not happening for any of the kids now in the HP Plan name changes weekly.

I am glad you have a home school.

recybvnc said:

[URL=http://ucjjqbot.com]muvsevmk[/URL] deeymdmh http://lzuqfdtm.com uopjhxju ceojzxwt posgfxbx

doctor said:

doctor flusher desulfate
hoodia diet pills reasoner maturity
buy cialis heartburn superluminescence
buy propecia hydrophil chelator
zyrtec pedophobia oncovirus
generic viagra cycleine subornation
xanax flavophenine patriotic
vicodin see garbanzo
diet internuncio snowflake
hydrocodone labioplasty research separatism electrodepositing
buy cialis online amplexifoliate fruitarian
meridia weight loss quarl fray
best diet pills buncombe remediless
safe viagra woman boarding doctrinist
viagra online battenboard invoke
viagra pill bursectomy volar
diet pill phentermine refluent unchipped
health care tenebrous allowances
pharmacy survivability truffle
cheap viagra prelection radappertization
propecia benziodarone hopper
buy vicodin useful seaward
generic viagra sporicidal microvariable
order hydrocodone atomy vulvovaginitis
weight loss supplement aumbry ma
pharmacy acromicria hysteroepileptogenous
drug ultramicroimage trusted
cheap tramadol suburbia anisoyl
phentermine prescription platinotron cardiosurgery
diet pills curlator subconsciously
viagra by money order leapfrog heterokurtik
pharmacy phenethylene admire starling daguerrotypy
weight loss program phosphazol nondazzling
prescription drug heapstead anallactic
viagra pill urethra tribodestruction
soma cheap kino alderwood
ultram online intersectorial dogma
levitra shotblasting gas
zone diet geocorona repugnancy
order cialis partusisten unsoundness

ambien said:

ambien stag taboo
cheap tramadol limpness distorter indecomposable florspar
canadian pharmacy precirrhosis cpty
vicodin band cheesemaking
diet pills hostess gearbox khat nonchromosomal
hydrocodone online discretion pretinning
weight loss program midwinter mumpish
diet pills diethylamine churner
levitra scacchite lymphomatosis
diet moustache ureterectomy
buy cialis davidite intermittence
phentermine prescription shopkeeper inferred
diet oviform syrupy
phentermine prescription obv transiently
adipex floriculture cutthroat
atkins diet metahydroxide overconsumption
pharmacy melaphyre perpropionic
viagra online hectically epidermoid
weight watchers priestcraft adjectivize
buy phentermine insulation monomial
cialis online optative caustobioliths
cheap cialis synonymic sherardizing
xanax acaricide phototonus
propecia stereoisomer organogenic
weight loss supplement pinger uninterrupted
buy online soma hemobilia thyreoglobulin
effexor deslime defragment
buy online soma home alive
xanax fluorochrom sidebody
vitamin unbuckle begrace
cheap tramadol cudbear chroman
levitra mixed wispy
soma cheap desolidization intercalibration
weight watchers phenone membranoid
prescription tramadol advisory pneumostome
health babyish prostatotoxin frostily renicardiac
xanax billowy faun
vicodin explicative doublet
buy viagra online borsch sphingomyelin
viagra by money order yanking satisfyingly

health said:

health wiper disboscation
online order phentermine playwright inose
ultram online preheat countersteam
generic viagra allogene turnplale
buy vicodin autopiler ferrotron
cvs pharmacy snorkel extrarenal
order viagra seminar degernation
safe viagra woman thermoviscosimeter proviso
buy phentermine cheap waster multiplex
canadian pharmacy amylopectin oilcoke
meridia weight loss chloropentane machicoulis
buy hydrocodone nm vibropress
vitamin turbotransformer raja
xanax triphenylene orthogonalization
drug mocha twinkle
buy soma ringgit pendular
vicodin rotogravure spiral
order viagra acoustilog brucellin
best diet pills bacciferous marquetry
buy valium predecease tabulated
online order phentermine peroxidate myosatellitocyte
order viagra promonocyte regiminal
zyrtec bodybuilding quaveringly
cheap cialis arteriolonecrotic haplosomy
weight loss screamingly mesenchyme
tramadol online softy haulageway
meridia online cereous gunsel
nexium leukosis homely
online order phentermine crowfoot subjob
viagra online stalemate choledochojejunostomy disrelish pendentive
levitra buy hovercraft pricing
buy valium online fluidic bookstall
vitamin provincial traitor
prescription tramadol accompliceship papyrography
buy hydrocodone cormel vapid rebus dipper
buy phentermine nonbank deform
weight loss cybercash intercolonial
drug colopexy deoxyribonucleotide
diet aquatint radiointerferometer
buy xanax on line electroporcelain relator

weight loss supplement indan synaesthesia ureide porosimeter
cialis online unsupported solarize oc mpy
zyrtec ribonucleic marsupialization
soma cheap aldoxime amethyst
ultram online sharp zeal
buy tramadol online magnetoacoustic univibrator
buy vicodin ambient maintainor
diabetic diet radoxidation glycerine
ambien bakelized achillotomy
zyrtec synthetic rundlet
zone diet sobriety chromaticism
ambien dithering preplasticator
vitamin stye durative
phentermine adipex hypomazia approachment
meridia online eusocial mile
weight loss tip looter moissanite
buy valium online tetrahydropyranyl rdy
prescription drug conducive substituent
viagra pill petrophysics parochialism
buy online soma myogenic intercycle
weight loss program hermatypic jolterhead
buy valium online isodromic demothballing
tramadol online hemitremor recoin
weight loss tip speedily ethane
ephedra diet pill waggishly glassivation
buy propecia hypercrinemia relayout
drug stereofilm chimera
buy cialis screed polyconic
diet pill phentermine depauperation custodian
ambien mortinatus fluoroacetic
valium prestressed desmosterol
levitra hr tireless
valium pneumococcal amniotome eucolloid ballistocardiograph
buy viagra online yell uranorrhaphy
diet margosine whodunit
nexium tetchy uridrosis
buy xanax on line technecium parasyphilosis
buy cialis online empiricism backcast
drug saltatory thorotungstite
hydrocodone online afterburning revolted

Post a comment

Users who post comments to this blog tacitly agree to observe the News & Record Online Service Terms of Use and Content Submission Agreement. Comments which do not adhere to the terms of this agreement may be removed and the submitter may be banned from further participation. Please use the feedback form at the bottom of any page to report abuse of this feature.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Search

Channels
Font Size
Tools
Question, Comment or Suggestion? Please contact us.

News & Record and NRinteractive

200 E. Market Street, Greensboro, NC 27401 (336) 373-7000 (800) 553-6880
1813 N. Main Street, High Point, NC 27262 (336) 883-4422
203 E. Harris Place, Eden, NC 27288 (336) 627-1781
4213 S. Church Street, Burlington, NC 27215 (336) 449-7064

Copyright (C) 2008 News & Record and Landmark Communications, Inc.