News-Record.com

The North Carolina Piedmont Triad's top go-to source for News
A service of the News & Record, Greensboro, North Carolina

Home

Thinking Out Loud

« Grimsley's choice | Main | More reader feedback »

This week's column

A friend of mine recently put his suburban house on the market. Then he took it off. Now he's considering putting it on again.

He's had it up to here with life in the hinterlands, where nobody knows your name. And apparently, nobody wants to.

Too many times, he says, he's said hello to people while jogging or taking a stroll. Too often they've looked at him as if he were crazy.

I don't know if it's fair to lump all of us suburbanites together in one big mass of self-absorption.

I, too, live in one of those far-off neighborhoods with wide streets, pastoral names, lots of cul-de-sacs and reasonably tasteful but not too expensive houses based on a half-dozen floor plans. People in my community are at least cordial and some are downright friendly. The neighborhood is racially mixed and generally peaceful. Many of us even clean up after our dogs.

But I must confess to feeling an occasional ache when visiting an old-school, in-close neighborhood such as Westerwood, Aycock, College Hill or Fisher Park.

There's a certain feel in those places that you don't seem to get in those sprawling, paint-by-the-numbers developments that stretch ever northward toward the Virginia border, where the last guy who moves in surely will be within walking distance of a lottery ticket.

Westerwood? you might wonder. Isn't that the place where the guy painted his house purple and where people are always at one another's throats?

Well, yeah. But there's also palpable warmth and feeling of community in Westerwood. Even the people who disagree know each other.

I recall a couple of summers ago, sitting on Diane Davis' front porch, sipping a Coke and witnessing a spirited discussion on whether Westerwood ought to be a historic district.

I also recall similar impressions in similar places that are all close to the city's heart. I remember sinking into the sofa in Beverly Morcos' 2,300-plus-square-foot apartment atop Liberty Oak Restaurant in the Vernon Building at South Elm and Washington.

I recall having cocktails in a Governor's Court condo on a steamy summer evening and admiring the view from a second-floor balcony. (Of course, that might be too close for comfort. I also could see my office window from there.)

Then there's Southside just outside the center city, a retro take on community-building that mixes restored homes with homes that feature living quarters upstairs and business downstairs.

Nearby, the Smothers Place Lofts already have sold out, but I'm not sure one would have been big enough for me anyway. I still need space for my dog and my model trains.

This is not to cast aspersions on where I live now. I like my house, even though it's one of what David Wharton has called a "snout house" on his blog, with the garage prominently jutting forward.

Wharton, an Aycock resident who likes to study neighborhoods and architecture as a pastime, believes snout houses are less inviting than other designs.

But I still like the open floor plan of my home -- and the center of my domestic universe, a junky bonus room over the garage where I can be happily unkempt, unshaven and undisturbed.

I am not as enamored of yard work. And I'm growing increasingly tired of increasingly longer commutes to work. It used to take 12 to 15 minutes to drive downtown. Now it takes more than 20.

Meanwhile, the landscape has changed downtown. Time was when there were few opportunities to buy a place there. Not anymore.

Who knows? Maybe I'll buy something on the 14th floor of the old Wachovia building (right after robbing the bank across the street).

Sure, some people complain that downtown lacks certain amenities, such as a grocery store. Well, so does my current neighborhood. It would take me only slightly longer to drive to Harris-Teeter in Friendly Center from downtown as it takes to drive to Harris-Teeter on Pisgah Church Road or the Food Lion on Lawndale.

Beyond these practical considerations are the less tangible ones. My neighborhood is a pleasant enough place but I'm not sure there's enough there there.

Of course, it could be a cop-out to look somewhere else for a magical formula. After all, it's the people who make a community, not the architectural styles or locations.

Maybe I still haven't invested enough in my community.

Maybe the pragmatic considerations hold more water than my armchair sociological theories.

Maybe I should move, but for the right reasons.

And maybe the real problem with where I live now is that there's not enough of me there.

Contact Allen H. Johnson at ajohnson@news-record.com

Comments (12)

To report abuse of the comment feature on this site, please use the feedback form at the bottom of any page.

jw said:

Mr. Wonderful has been thinking that perhaps it is time to think about moving since Bundle of Joy #3 is heading off to college in the fall and the suburban house in which we raised three children might be a little big for us. (If we downsize QUICKLY maybe they won't come back!) Unfortunately we disagree on WHERE we should live. I say a flat in downtown Greensboro. He said a ranch house WAY out in the country. He wants to see a real estate agent. I want to see a lawyer. It's complicated.

quest said:

Allen,

The neighborhood you describe sounds exactly like the one I live in in High Point. I live in a very diverse neighborhood, people are generally friendly toward one another, and most people do pick up after their dogs.

I bet there's one major difference. I bet the kids in your neighborhood know where they will attend High School. I bet your neighborhood won't be divided up among 3 Greensboro High Schools. I bet the kids in your neighborhood have a traditional neighborhood high school. I bet the kids in your neighborhood aren't forced to a magnet school regardless of their desire for the particular subject.

Be glad for the neighborhood you have. The Guilford County Board of Education has managed to kill the term neighborhood here in High Point.

I agree that schools can provide precious "glue" for a community. But I dare suggest that there would be no need for magnets or "choice plans" if we could master the still-evasive art of living together.
Too many of our neighborhoods remain segregated.

quest said:

Allen,

As long as the parents voluntarily choose to send their children to a magnet school, it is fine with me. What is offensive is that those in High Point send their children to magnet schools against their will.

Are you stating that it is the job of the school system to ensure that neighborhoods have increased integration?

No. I'm simply saying that it makes life harder for school administrators when we don't take care of that job ourselves. Here it is, 2005, and we are still too segregated as a society.

Also thinking outloud said:

Allen,

Although I can see Asians, white, and blacks from my porch in the neighboring houses, I would have to be honest and say that the majority of my neighborhood is white.

Also, BOTH of the houses on either side of my house are for sale. Are you suggesting that it's my responsibility to make sure that a minorities buy these houses?

How do we "take care of that job ourselves" as you state above?? Should I give a black family money to buy it if they can't afford it?? Should the realtor ONLY advertise this for sale "for black or minority families only"?

Please clarify just how it is that we should go about this.

No, I am not suggesting that.
I am only hoping that, assuming you are white, you would not move if a pair of black families bought those homes.
There still is something in real estate called the "tipping point." According to this phenomenon, a smattering of black families is OK. But if a neighborhood exceeds a certain percentate of black residents, then whites have tended to move away.

Also thinking outloud said:

Mr. Johnson,

Yes, your assumption is correct, I'm white. Would I move if black families moved in? No, nor have I ever known a family that has done this.

The only "Tipping Point" I'm aware of right now is the one being created by our School Board and Superintendent.

It goes like this: Your schools are screwed with....some families move away. Your schools are screwed with even more....you're "tipped" over the edge, and you move.

I understand your concern about the schools.
Hete is an excerpt from a 2001 News & Record article that explains the racial tipping point. I know it's a little long but I didn't want to lose the context.

During the last decade:
More black people moved into what were once mostly white neighborhoods.
The Triad, along with the rest of the Southeast, grew, and people of all races moved into new subdivisions not labeled as historically white or black.
The minority population grew faster than the white population.
Despite these changes, many Triad neighborhoods remain mostly white or black.
"Segregation's not crumbling; it's being chipped away," said Steve Lilley, a demographer and sociology professor at N.C. State.
"It's an important and notable trend because residential barriers are the last major barriers between whites and African Americans," Lilley said. "We attend the same schools, shop in the same stores and work on the same jobs. Where we live is one of the real last bastions of segregation anywhere."
David Kline saw that while house-hunting when he moved to Greensboro from Pennsylvania two years ago.
"It was very apparent when we moved here," said Kline, 48, a white man who bought a home in The Reserve community in north Greensboro. "The east end of town was black, and the west end was white."
About one of every two black people or one of every two white people would have to move to completely integrate Guilford County's blacks and whites.
"Race still matters," said Robert Davis, a sociologist and associate vice-chancellor at N.C. A&T who has studied segregation.
Just how much race matters, though, is difficult to gauge. The News & Record interviewed about two dozen people in Greensboro about segregation, in neighborhoods ranging from very mixed to majority white or majority black. The subject makes some people uncomfortable. They will not discuss it or will offer candid opinions only anonymously.
That's the baggage of history, Davis said.
"We live in a society where we have a history of slavery, and following slavery, a history of Jim Crow," or legalized segregation, Davis said. "All of that has colored how we see each other."
That history, he said, includes barriers to blacks living where they want to, such as real estate agents steering them to black neighborhoods, banks scrutinizing their loan applications more critically and many blacks not earning as much as whites.
"If the market was driving it, if it was what you could afford, then poor white people and poor black people would be in the same neighborhoods," Davis said. "Middle-class black people would be in the same neighborhoods with middle-class white people."
Integration is rising because more racial minorities, mostly blacks, are living in what were once mostly white communities. The prosperous 1990s helped.
"Housing is largely a function of income, and as income increases for the various groups, they can afford to move where they want to," Lilley said.
A decade ago, 55 percent of Guilford County's census block groups -- areas several city blocks wide -- were at least 80 percent white. Now, only 38 percent of block groups are 80 percent white.
Some of that change, though, could be a statistical mirage.
The U.S. Census Bureau combined some of the smaller block groups to form new, larger block groups for the 2000 Census, merging data from several neighborhoods. So it is difficult to measure how individual communities have changed.
Integration has increased, but not enough for some.
Karen Sofia and her husband were the third family to buy in their Summerfield subdivision.
She watched with some concern when most all the homes built after hers -- except for four bought by Lebanese families -- were snapped up by other white families.
"I like my neighbors. But (the lack of diversity) is one of the few things I don't like," said Sofia, a 36-year-old nurse. She's considering sending her children to magnet schools so they can appreciate diversity.
Other people -- black and white -- are more apprehensive about diversity and tend to seek out neighborhoods where their race predominates.
"Some people don't want to live with people who do not look like them," Davis said. "Black people have those concerns. Whites might feel uncomfortable saying that because they don't know how to express that sentiment without appearing racist."
Some white or mixed neighborhoods do become all black because white families feel threatened and move out.
"It's something called the tipping point -- white families will allow some blacks to move in," said Davis. "But once the percentage gets to 15 percent, whites start feeling uncomfortable. By 30 percent, the 'For Sale' signs start going up."

Also Thinking Out Loud said:

Thank you for the 2001 article.

It has points that could be argued, especially the "Whites feeling uncomfortable at 15%..." But for the most part I will not argue with history. I will just say that I hope with each year the disparity improves. I too, a "whitey" and a "yankee" to boot--embrace diversity at home and in schools.

What we must remember though, it cannot be forced, just as it couldn't be bused.


The only "For Sale" signs I see NOW in my neighborhood are due to school issues. This new "tipping point" should be just as concerning as the one that you point out.

Thanks for taking time to read that long excerpt.
I understand your passion about the schools. These issues are complex and emotional, but I believe they can be solved if they are viewed as community issues -- and if we all consider the broader implications beyond our individual blocks or neighborhoods.
I know that isn't always easy but it is the only way to get past the problems we're seeing today.

Post a comment

Users who post comments to this blog tacitly agree to observe the News & Record Online Service Terms of Use and Content Submission Agreement. Comments which do not adhere to the terms of this agreement may be removed and the submitter may be banned from further participation. Please use the feedback form at the bottom of any page to report abuse of this feature.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Search

Channels
Font Size
Tools
Question, Comment or Suggestion? Please contact us.

News & Record and NRinteractive

200 E. Market Street, Greensboro, NC 27401 (336) 373-7000 (800) 553-6880
1813 N. Main Street, High Point, NC 27262 (336) 883-4422
203 E. Harris Place, Eden, NC 27288 (336) 627-1781
4213 S. Church Street, Burlington, NC 27215 (336) 449-7064

Copyright (C) 2008 News & Record and Landmark Communications, Inc.