Keeping it too simple?
A critical report on the current installment of HBO's superb series, "Real Sports," takes issue with media coverage of the Duke lacrosse rape case, citing the use of misleading generalizations and stereotypes to feed a more compelling story line.
For instance, the piece notes that stories have depicted Duke as a rich white school and N.C. Central as a poor black school, despite the fact that Duke's undergraduate enrollment is 32 percent minority and NCCU's is 13 percent white.
Further,the piece noted the higher education bond construction boom at Central and included footage of buildings that weren't ragged or crumbling, contrary to some out-of-state depictions.
The piece also included an interview with the NCCU student body president, who flatly dismissed the idea that all NCCU students believe that the lacrosse players are automatically guilty. He said he'd simply like to see justice done. (There are interviews with a white NCCU student and a Latina student as well.)
Personally, I've noticed the almost total lack of context about Durham's heritage as a mecca for black business and black achievement, and its formidable black middle class.
You'd expect from some reports that Rod Steiger's big-bellied sheriff from "In the Heat of the Night" was about to swagger in at any moment.
Comments (2)
To report abuse of the comment feature on this site, please use the feedback form at the bottom of any page.
Villainizing and depicting a school as white, elitist no matter the truth, thus packaging a narrative supporting the cause of someone's political advantage-seeking.
Hmmm...how rare.
Posted on May 25, 2006 3:50 PM
When the media has a compelling cultural myth and facts that bear some tentative relation to it, it will recycle the myth with but a glance at the facts. Look at the Katrina coverage, most of which turns out to be wrong.
On the other hand, and while I theoretically support the primacy of fact, I really can't get too worked up over Duke being treated this way . . . because it's Duke.
Posted on May 25, 2006 11:58 PM