I admit it. Post NFL Draft analysis is a guilty pleasure for me. I know, I know, it's really silly and arbitrary to give out grades a day after an event that really can't be accurately judged until these guys, you know, actually play. But I eat this stuff up. I really do. And I'm betting you do as well.
That's why I'm providing all the links below to let you know what the "experts" think of the Carolina Panthers' draft. As the title to this post says, in general they think the Panthers done good.
Paul Zimmerman - aka Dr. Z - gave the Panthers a B. Yeah, it's not an A, but for a curmudgeon like Zimmerman, who doles out praise in very, very small amounts, it might as well be.
Another SI writer, Don Banks, didn't do grades, but did set aside a graph or two to praise what the Panthers did in their draft.
John Czarnecki over at Fox Sports wasn't that high on Jon Beason Carolina's first pick, but still gave the Panthers an A. Why? He was gaga over the second round picks. Like SI's Peter King, he loves USC C Ryan Kalil. And he adamantly stated that USC WR Dwayne Jarrett was "no Mike Williams"
(Personal aside here. I can't help but think that Jarrett probably would have gone earlier had he not gone to Southern Cal. I know it seems strange to say, but follow my reasoning here. Like Williams, Jarrett was a long, tall ultra-productive receiver for the Trojans. Like Williams, Jarrett didn't run a very fast 40 time on pro day. Williams, as we all know, turned out to be a massive bust for the Lions. So therefore, Jarrett must be another bust, like Williams, right? Never mind that Williams already had the infamous "character issues" before going to the NFL and had already missed a season of college ball before he went to the Lions. I'm telling you, if Jarrett had gone to college somewhere else, the Williams comparisons wouldn't have been so obvious and the guy probably goes in the mid to late first-round. Weird, but I really think NFL GMs sometimes suffer from Groupthink on things like this.)
Pete Prisco at CBS.Sportsline.com gave the Panthers a B+. He too loved the Jarrett pick. His only complaint was a really nitpicky one. He wouldn't have drafted a return specialist - Ryne Robinson - in the fourth round.
Finally, Chris Neubauer, an associate editor at Pro Football Weekly, felt the Panthers did the best job on the first day of the draft. Like several other experts, he loved that Carolina was able to trade down in the first round - picking up extra picks in the process - and still get the same player at No. 25 (Beason) that it wanted at No. 14.
What does all of this mean? Not much until these guys actually take the field. But for Panthers fans who had to suffer through last season's disappointment, it's at least a good start for the 2007 campaign.