In a state of confusion
Wednesday's lead editorial.
If North Carolina wants a clear policy for admitting illegal immigrants to community colleges and UNC institutions, the legislature needs to write it soon. All is confusion now.
The past week has seen this baffling series of events:
• The N.C. Attorney General’s Office advised the state community college system to reverse its six-month-old directive that “colleges should immediately begin admitting undocumented individuals.”
• Gov. Mike Easley urged community colleges to keep enrolling illegal immigrants anyway.
• Both candidates for governor, Democrat Bev Perdue and Republican Pat McCrory, said they disagree with Easley and the community college policy.
• The U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency contradicted the attorney general’s advice, saying federal law doesn’t prevent states from admitting illegal immigrants from public colleges and universities.
• The community college system announced it would follow the attorney general’s advice and, beginning immediately, “no longer admit individuals classified as illegal or undocumented immigrants into curriculum degree programs.”
This fast-paced zig-zag traces the nation’s convoluted thinking about immigration. People cross the border illegally to find work, and a U.S. Supreme Court ruling says their children are entitled to free public education through 12th grade. Some states have decided it makes sense to allow those who qualify academically to continue their education in public colleges and universities, enabling them to find more meaningful employment and become contributors to society ... except that employers technically aren’t supposed to hire undocumented immigrants.
The community college system waded into this stew, but only up to its ankles. It counted no more than 112 undocumented curriculum-degree students enrolled in its 58 colleges this year, and all pay tuition at the out-of-state rate. Certainly, many more would follow if they were permitted, but that won’t happen without further legal review or a vigorous public debate.
JB Kelly, the general counsel who wrote the advisory letter on behalf of N.C. Attorney General Roy Cooper, admitted some questions about the application of federal law are unsettled. But in an interview Monday, he expressed certainty that the state legislature has full authority to enact an open-door policy in regard to immigration status for the UNC and community college systems.
There’s not much chance that Raleigh politicians will solve the immigration riddles that stump the best minds in Congress. The state can’t deport illegal immigrants or grant them legal status. It has no choice but to educate their children through high school. But it can decide whether to grant or deny them a path to public postsecondary education. It’s time to straighten out the zig-zag quandary on the enrollment question.
Comments (3)
To report abuse of the comment feature on this site, please use the feedback form at the bottom of any page.
BULLFEATHERS! Illegal means illegal. What you are saying if you live in Va. you must pay out of state tuition. If you just jumped the boarder you get to attend on the taxpayers dime .Not to mention, the number of NC students that are denied college , because the seats are taking by illegals. I like to see just one person at this paper say this is right.
Posted on May 14, 2008 5:42 AM
I think this article is right in saying we need to straighten this mess out. Virginia has implemented a policy to deny college enrollment to illegal aliens - a policy ruled constitutional in the 2004 case Equal Access Ed. v. Merten. Only the state legislature -- not the Department of Homeland Security or the N.C. Community College System or the UNC system -- has the authority to decide this issue. But if voter sentiment is any indication -- see nccivitas.org for more on that -- then legislators will act soon to prohibit illegals from attending all public colleges and universities in North Carolina.
Posted on May 14, 2008 4:55 PM
All of us are do illegal things too, the only difference is usually are not caught. Do you deserve to go back to your home country? Europe? Because as long as I know the Native-Americans are the only real owners of this land. Coming to this lands and almost exterminating native people was the way we made it. They didn’t like us much did they? Otherwise we would not have fought wars with them or kill them. So now you see some people coming here in peace, looking for a job and you call them illegal? HEY!! At least they are doing it peacefully. And yeah yeah yeah, I know what the media says they all have criminal records.. right.. but I have seen other better reports where they say immigrants have less incidence of crime then American born people. Of course you uneducated, old, republican, southern people do not agree. However you go to church every Sunday and say you believe in Jesus, who brought love and peace to the world, and not greed, war, racism, and prejudism. Hey!! by the way, why not send all the lazy people to somewhere else instead of illegal aliens? Illegal aliens work and produce, the lazy people don’t, plus they suck all social services that illegal aliens are not entitled and cannot get, but yeahh you like them sucking your blood and don’t say anything.
Posted on June 5, 2008 12:41 AM